Safe Utility Tunnelling Through Tailor-Made Hard-Software
Nov 02, 2020
The process engineering limits of pipe jacking have shifted considerably in recent years. Jacking lengths of 800 m and more are no longer a special feature. Narrow bends and S-curves appear more and more frequently in the tenders of the network operators and are usually executed without major problems. The reason for this extremely positive development lies not only in the constantly increasing wealth of experience of the mostly specialized companies in Germany, but also in the integration of customized hardware and software into the daily pipe jacking routine. Some products, which guarantee static safety in particular, will be presented in this article.
Static jacking support (Monitoring of joint gap differences)
On this basis, so-called pipe joint monitoring systems have been established (e.g. CoJack from STEIN Ingenieure), which now do much more than just monitor the pipe joints. Rather, these systems serve as a continuous static control instrument during jacking to determine the current stress on the jacking pipes and even enable a constantly updated forecast of the steering movements and jacking forces that will just be permissible in the future.
Thus, the observer can always judge at first glance whether the current jacking parameters are within the permissible range. Dangerous tendencies can be detected at an early stage so that countermeasures can be taken in time. This illustration of the otherwise mostly completely invisible static stresses on the jacking pipes is not only used by the Employer and construction supervisors as a control instrument. The jacking companies carrying out the work have also come to appreciate and even learn to use the transparency of the jacking data.
They can use CoJack to prove that the permissible pipe stresses are being adhered to and, if necessary, have a statically secure basis for optimising their jacking progress. CoJack provides information as to whether higher jacking forces are permitted if necessary or with which force the jacking may be continued immediately after an excessive steering movement. The safety level prescribed in the regulations is always maintained.
The optional measurement and display of the jacking force not only at the main jacking station, but also at all installed intermediate jacking stations, contributes to this. This even works when the intermediate jacking stations are not actively used at all and are only passively pushed along. For this purpose, the jacking cylinders have to be extended just a few centimeters. Thus, the jacking force applied by the main jacking station is transmitted within the passive jacking cylinders of the intermediate jacking station via the oil cushion (see Figure 1).
By observing the jacking force progression, it is possible to localise jacking sections with increased jacking resistance if necessary. An additional help for the interpretation of the jacking force diagrams is the representation of the jacking cylinders expansion of the intermediate jacking stations, which allows a local and temporal allocation of the intermediate jacking stations activities.
Lubrication and measuring systems
If the positions or the sections with increased resistances are located in this way, modern lubrication systems can condition the grouting of the annular space in a very specific way. Not only with a sense of proportion and gut feeling, but also volume-controlled and/or pressure-controlled, a defined quantity of the lubricant and supporting agent (bentonite) can be introduced into the annular gap between soil and jacking pipe at each lubrication station (position in the pipe string) or even at each lubrication outlet.
If the grouting is carried out sufficiently slowly, i.e. with sufficiently low flow rates and speeds, the injection pressure at the lubrication outlet can even be estimated via the pressure transducer located above ground.
In recent years, quality-enhancing further developments have been made not only in lubrication technology but also in measurement technology. Although the basic techniques of measurement for machine control by means of laser or gyro compass have remained the same, the associated software has developed in great strides. For example, modern surveying systems can now be set up by remote control, and remote maintenance from the manufacturer's office avoids unnecessary journeys.
The greatest advantage is the reduction of downtimes, which on the one hand represent a large cost factor and on the other hand can lead to technical problems in the form of increased jacking resistance when restarting.
In addition, software products are available on the market which not only document the data mentioned in Worksheet DWA-A 125, Section 7.2.6, in tabular form in compliance with the regulations in printable form, but also prepare them and display them in clearly understandable form online in a graphic format. CoJack covers the statically relevant part of this data and additionally compares the measurement data with the permissible data in a graphical form. This also allows the observer who does not necessarily want to delve into the finer details of pipe statics to draw the right conclusions from the measurement data.
Such a method is CoJack, which is in full compliance with the rules and regulations, but usually - due to the internal upstream determination of a jacking specific load history - allows significantly higher jacking forces. This sometimes makes the second curve in the route possible in the first place. It is pleasing that the static safety is not reduced by this, but even increased by the more precise calculation.
The hydraulic joint
In contrast, the latest developments in pressure transfer means for the transfer of jacking force from pipe to pipe can be classified as pure hardware products. The aim is to replace the transfer of dynamic forces by means of a "crushed" chipboard ring, which seems rather anachronistic to today's engineers, with a modern method. Most pressure transfer rings made of different materials failed due to their suitability or cost and have been used in practice only sporadically so far.
Only the hydraulic joint, on the other hand, is becoming increasingly important and, after overcoming teething troubles, is a technical and often also economic alternative, if one compares the higher direct costs for the joint itself compared to the wooden pressure transfer ring with the indirect savings (longer jacking pipes, higher jacking forces, faster installation, more diverse possibilities for line management).
The jacking force is transferred very elegantly via a water cushion enclosed in the hydraulic hose. Since liquids have the unique property of exerting the same pressure at every point and in every direction, the pipe end faces are subjected to the same pressure all around, even in tight bends, which can also be calculated quite easily depending on the jacking force. The stress on the pipes is therefore
- uniform without local stress peaks,
- easy and precise to calculate
- largely indepedent of joint bending (cornering).
In addition, the hydraulic joint has no "memory" and, unlike the wooden pressure transfer ring, is not adversely affected by an unfavorable load history (e.g. high tensions in previous curves). Since the static calculation of the pipe stresses contains fewer imponderables, the security with regard to overstressing is greater.
The latest developments in hydraulic joint manufacturing even allow a technically and economically interesting dual function of the hydraulic joint (TuSo HD-Sealing system). In the jacking phase, the hose has the described function as a pressure transfer medium. After completion of the jacking in the operating phase, the hose also takes over the function of the internal joint seal, thus saving the installation of a complex caulking seal, which would have to be tailor made and correctly installed for each joint.
The hydraulic hose alone does not constitute a seal due to its surface and hardness, but a coating with an additional sealing hose made of softer elastomer prevents the penetration of the waste water. Its hardness is optimised in such a way that on the one hand it transmits the jacking forces undamaged via its wall, but on the other hand it clings to the concrete surface with such a positive fit that it fulfils the function of an internal joint seal (also known as an internal seal). The necessary contact pressure is applied solely via the jacking force.
Optionally, once the pipeline has been immovably integrated into the shaft structure, a defined pressure can be set and documented in the hydraulic hoses. A pressure control and readjustment is possible at defined intervals in order to adjust the jacking pipe position to any changes in the situation.
In this way, the appropriately conditioned hydraulic joint not only increases the static safety during jacking, but also the safety with regard to corrosion of the pressure transfer ring.
In addition, the hose can of course also serve as an internal abutment for grouting processes. However, it must be remembered that the grouting material introduced will more or less impair the articulation of the pipe connection, depending on its rigidity. The introduction of a cement-bound grout leads to a complete stiffening and thus to an undesirable rigid pipe string.
Any small subsequent ground displacement, for example as a result of adjacent construction measures, changes in the groundwater level or mining-related subsidence, leads to uncontrolled damage in the form of cracks or spalling on the pipes, so that the already self-sealing hose without grouting represents the safer solution.
In recent years, numerous new and further developments have contributed to a significant increase in static safety in the area of pipe jacking, although the number of pipe jacking sections that can be classified as difficult in the tenders of network operators is increasing. The willingness to carry out measures in difficult ground, with long lengths and daring routes with S and space curves has increased. Using new methods of monitoring, online statics, pressure transfer methods and improved methods of lubrication and surveying, these jacking projects are often mastered without major problems in combination with the extensive experience of the jacking companies.
|Kind of joint||Wooden pressure transfer ring||
|Required static control||Without monitoring||with CoJack*|
Straight section or
R > 500 x DA
|L < 100 m||L > 100 m||Not required|
|A curve in the course of advance||Not recommended||R > 150 x DA||R < 150 x DA|
|Several curves in the course of driving||Not recommended||R > 200 x DA||R < 200 x DA|
*Online static monitoring
The most far-reaching innovations that both the clients and the construction companies first had to familiarise themselves with were the joint monitoring programs (static monitoring systems) as software and the hydraulic joint as hardware. In the meantime, these applications, which were initially viewed with suspicion, have become widely established. Table 1 shows under which conditions the hydraulic joint should be used for a safe jacking project and when a static jacking support (for example with CoJack) is sufficient. Furthermore, it remains to be seen to what extent the increase in transparency regarding the jacking data, which is highly esteemed by all sides, will continue.
More News and Articles
Sep 29, 2023
Researchers from the University of Illinois Chicago have proposed a “dual-pipeline” solution to address the region’s water supply issues. The system would feature one line supplying industrial sites with treated wastewater and another conveying drinking water to homes and other …
Sep 27, 2023
New e-learning module of the course BE-07 Investigation and Inspection of Sewers and Pipelines now available on UNITRACC!
Sep 27, 2023
Any water loss through leaking pipes is unacceptable in the eyes of the public, and on the launch of a deep-dive leakage report from Ovarro, technology leader for leakage solutions, Barbara Hathaway, explains how technologies continue to advance.
Sep 25, 2023
Pumping liquids may seem like a solved problem, but optimizing the process is still an area of active research. Any pumping application—from industrial scales to heating systems at home—would benefit from a reduction in energy demands. Researchers at the Institute …
Sep 22, 2023
PPXXI Conference and Exhibition welcomes McElroy Manufacturing, Inc. as the mobile app sponsor. Their sponsorship enhances networking opportunities for the delegates. Scheduled over September 25 -27, 2023, in Lake Buena Vista, Florida, PPXXI is the key technical and business event …
Sep 20, 2023
Aquatech is the leading water technology show in the world, with over 800 exhibitors and expecting over 22,000 visitors from over 140+ countries.
Sep 18, 2023
Designed to reduce pollution in Lake Erie by four billion gallons per year, Project Clean Lake is a 25-year plan being overseen by Cleveland's Northeast Ohio Regional Sewer District (NEORSD). When construction crews complete the $3 billion undertaking in 2036, …
Sep 13, 2023
Mullane once again proved why the company is an industry leader in pipeline solutions with a relining project on the mid north coast of New South Wales.
Sep 11, 2023
Pezzimenti Trenchless continues to showcase its position as a leading trenchless specialist by completing works on two Victorian projects.
Sep 08, 2023
Silvertown Tunnel under Thames - Newham to Greenwich near O2 Arena: See two massive boreholes in east London
The second of two boreholes beneath the Thames – which will together form London’s new Silvertown Tunnel – is now complete.
Sep 04, 2023
Report highlights American Water’s sustainable impact on communities across the U.S.
Aug 31, 2023
Anaergia Selected to Design, Build and Operate Organic Waste-to-Renewable Energy Project in San Diego County
System to provide renewable power, reduce wastewater utility costs, and cut greenhouse gas emissions for East County Advanced Water Purification facility.