Maximise HDD accuracy with combined guidance technologies
Feb 14, 2024
As the underground grows more crowded, the industry is under pressure to deliver highly accurate installations through a web of existing infrastructure.
Vector Magnetics director of marketing Jed Sheckler discusses in Trenchless Australasia how the trenchless industry can palliate this pressure through horizontal directional drilling (HDD). HDD has become an essential part of the expansion and replacement of critical data, electrical, water, energy, and waste networks, with proven effectiveness across a diverse range of installations.
Exploring the practical limits of HDD accuracy has become a popular topic of discussion within the trenchless community. In a year when both the North American Society for Trenchless Technology (NASTT) and European Drilling Contractors Association (DCA) are updating their best practices and guidelines, it is important to have a clear understanding of the role of guidance systems in maximising the accuracy of the HDD process.
Guidance overview
HDD guidance systems have generally been classified as either walkover (small rig) or wireline (large rig). However, the term wireline simply refers to one type of power and data transmission method which may be utilised by rigs of any size. The term downhole more appropriately describes a guidance system capable of operating without surface access, and with no inherent depth limitation. Downhole systems may be classified as magnetic downhole, gyroscopic downhole or combo systems. As shown in Table 1, there are several methods of guiding a HDD pilot bore. While details may differ depending on the manufacturer’s approach, a complete HDD guidance system must provide the following capabilities:
- Steering puts the directional in HDD: The drilling assembly is fitted with an offset bit, sub, or motor. An accelerometer in the steering tool informs the driller of the current inclination and roll-angle. Orienting the offset and pushing (sliding) the drill string without rotation provides directional control of the borehole.
- Surveying calculates the location of the pilot bore as it progresses: Surveys are taken at discrete positions (typically when making a drill rod connection) when there is no fluid flow, and the sensors are most stable. HDD survey tools (downhole magnetic or gyro) measure the orientation of the tool relative to the earth’s poles (azimuth) and gravitational field (pitch). These values are combined with total drill pipe length (measured depth) to calculate the current position relative to a known starting point, typically the bore entry point (Figure 1).
- Tracking verifies the calculated survey position by making direct measurements relative to external reference points. A tracking source (ParaTrack2 electrical cable, Beacon Tracker, Microcoil, etc.) is placed at a known location on surface or run through an adjacent, completed conduit. The source is periodically electrified and emits an electro-magnetic signal sensed by the magnetometers in the survey tool. The signal is emitted from a known location, at a known intensity, at a known frequency, providing a series of additional tie points that greatly increases the accuracy of the surveyed position (Figure 2).
Sources of error
While technological advancements have greatly improved the quality of HDD surveys, it is important to understand the types of errors that may act independently or in combination to influence the accuracy of an HDD guidance system. Random errors are unpredictable and may appear as though no one sample repeats (low precision).
However, the impact of random errors is minimised by increasing the sample size and averaging. Adequate sampling makes it possible to obtain accurate answers from highly random data sets. Systematic errors are consistent and reproducible, imparting a bias to the data. When drilling on survey data alone, without the benefit of additional tie points from an external tracking source, systematic error will typically become the main source of positional uncertainty over long-distances (>300m). Gross errors are, in short, typically caused by human error.
Gross errors can be especially difficult to detect as they cannot be modeled or effectively planned for. Gross errors include input errors (moving a decimal point), transcription errors (flipping a sign, transposing a digit), or operational errors due to a lack of training, etc.
Ellipse of uncertainty
While all three types of errors may act independently or in combination, it is widely accepted that the majority of borehole surveying uncertainty is due to systematic errors in the surveying system. Small errors in inclination, azimuth, and depth systematically accumulate. This accumulation forms an ellipse of uncertainty regarding the true position of an inclined borehole that grows as a function of drilled length (Figure 3).
Maximum accuracy, minimum risk
The positional uncertainty that results when a pilot bore is guided from a single tie point presents a risk that all parties must be aware of when considering the available technology. A guidance system combining a precision survey (gyro or magnetic) with secondary tracking (ParaTrack2 electrical cable, Beacon Tracker System, Microcoil) that identifies and corrects for any induced error results in the highest achievable accuracy for HDD (Figure 4). Modern HDD job sites fuse the latest technological advancements with the realities of getting product in the ground.
Above all is the need to identify potential sources of risk that could slow progress, result in an accidental strike, or worse yet, cause the project to fail entirely. A clear understanding of the capabilities and limitations of available guidance technology ensures constructable designs with tolerances that can be realistically followed, maximising the chances of a successful outcome.
More News and Articles
Jul 24, 2024
News
UK utilities place multiple orders for settlement tank technology
Northumbrian Water, Southern Water, and Dŵr Cymru upgrading wastewater sites
Three UK water utilities have agreed orders for the installation of a total of six conical settlement …
Jul 22, 2024
Article
Reusing wastewater, rethinking water: Maharashtra's roadmap
How Maharashtra turns wastewater into a resource
Water resource management is a critical issue globally, and in India, the state of Maharashtra is pioneering efforts to regulate and …
Jul 19, 2024
News
Kansas City advances fire hydrant leak detection technology
An acoustic fixed-base pipe monitoring technology that uses fire hydrants to host multi-sensor devices, has already found more than 30 leaks for Kansas City Water, says Lou Rossetti …
Jul 17, 2024
News
When two bores right a wrong
The Edge Underground team is adamant: there is always a risk of things going wrong on a trenchless project, even for the most prepared contractor.
Experience and having the right equipment can be the difference between …
Jul 15, 2024
News
Adapting to a region’s growing water and wastewater needs
Gippsland Water has completed two major projects to provide local communities with water security. Trenchless Australasia takes a look at the two projects helping increase water supply …
Jul 12, 2024
News
Connections made in Glastonbury
Difficult ground conditions called for a specialist solution when new PE pipes for potable water services had to be installed underneath two, 10-metre road crossings in the grounds of the UK’s ultimate music festival …
Jul 10, 2024
Article
The Water-Energy Nexus: Interdependence and Challenges
Niclas Andersson, CEO of AirWater2All, explains the connection between water and energy. The importance of this connection and the areas in which it needs to be considered are explained …
Jul 08, 2024
News
Minimising cultural impacts with trenchless technology
Yarra Valley Water is leveraging the benefits of trenchless technology to lessen impacts on the Upper Darebin Creek branch sewer project.
The project consists of building a 2.7km sewer pipe …
Jul 05, 2024
News
SprayWall: Reinforcing Underground Infrastructure with Unmatched Strength
In the trenchless technology industry, finding a rehabilitation solution that offers ease of installation and exceptional structural integrity is paramount.
For three decades, …
Jul 01, 2024
News
“Don’t let stereotypes hold you back”
Trenchless Australasia sat down with Rob Carr project manager Marie Piette to discuss her career and work at the microtunnelling contracting company.
From Norway to Cambodia and now Perth, Western Australia, …
Jun 28, 2024
News
Transforming Wastewater: Towards Climate-Neutral Sewage Treatment
Baden-Württemberg’s Minister President Winfried Kretschmann recently toured the Büsnau Training and Research Sewage Treatment Plant, where a pioneering project led by researchers …
Jun 26, 2024
News
Bothar advances with significant new contracts
Having commenced work on the Fitzroy to Gladstone Pipeline earlier this year, Bothar Boring and Tunnelling has announced the award of further contracts as part of its ongoing collaboration with …
Contact
Trenchless Australasia
379 Docklands Dr,
VIC 3008 Docklands
Australia
Phone:
+61 3 9690 8766